In present-day Toronto, Greek gods Apollo and Hermes give 15 dogs human intelligence, allowing them to maintain their dog memories. The chapter explores the dogs’ diverging reactions to their new capacities. 

Apollo and Hermes’s bet begins with a debate about whether humans are better or worse than other creatures. Apollo argues that humans “have no special merit” (13) and only “think themselves superior” (15). Hermes disagrees, citing humans’ abilities to create and use symbols. Apollo bets Hermes that animals granted human intelligence will be no happier than humans are. Fifteen dogs residing at a veterinary clinic become the bet’s subjects. If even one dies happy, Hermes will win.

The dogs immediately begin experiencing complex emotions and thoughts and expanding their language. Majnoun, a black poodle, figures out how to open his cell, and the other dogs follow accordingly. Leaving the clinic, they feel “helplessly free” (17) and concerned about who will lead them. 

Three of the dogs decide to stay behind. Agatha suffers extreme pain. Before receiving intelligence, the clinic was set to euthanize her. She dies frightened, wishing to see her “mistress” one last time. Ronaldinho and Lydia return to their humans. Ronaldinho dies “bitter and disillusioned” (18) by his humans’ condescension.