As Agnes and Chuck continue to play the module, Miles enters the room and admits that he misinterpreted her relationship with Chuck. Concerned that Agnes is angry with him, Miles invites her back to their apartment so they can make up, but she has no interest in leaving the game. Chuck, who makes fun of Miles for his assumptions and competitiveness, nevertheless steps in and invites him to join their game. Agnes assumes that Miles won’t play, but to her surprise, he eagerly joins because he understands that the game is important to her. Miles comments that she never speaks about the tragic loss of her family members and expresses a desire to get to know Agnes better through the game. When he joins the party, Agnes introduces him as her boyfriend, the “real Miles,” and defends his participation by stating that she trusts him to support her.

The party sets off to find the third guardian, The Beholder, but they are waylaid by the return of Evil Gabbi and Evil Tina. Miles mistakenly thinks he can fend them off alone and is the first one to die. The Succubi corner Tilly, and when Lilith jumps in to protect her, they stab and kill Lilith.