The Yankees score four runs in the top of the first against Tripp Lyons, the best pitcher on the Cardinals—their “ace.” To stop another run, Hutch dives and throws out a runner from his knees. The Yankees score another run later, so they lead 5–0 when Alex Reyes, the centerfielder, bunts for a hit, Brett walks, and Hutch hits a home run. After Darryl doubles in Hank, the Cardinals are within a run, 5–4.

The scores remain 5–4 in the bottom of the ninth. Alex is on first, and Hutch bats next. Violating protocols, Darryl stands with Hutch in the on-deck circle and alerts him about the presence of a reporter and a photographer from The Palm Beach Post. A Channel 12 crew is also in the building. Darryl wants Hutch to get on base, then Darryl can win the game and be on “the news.”

As Hutch walks toward the plate, he sees his dad and hears him reminding him not to pull the ball. After a few questionable strike calls, Hutch hits a home run, and the Cardinals win 6–5. A TV camera focuses on Hutch, who feels like he is “floating.”