An impressive friar arrives in Lynn but is unwilling to put up with Margery’s weeping during his sermons. Her detractors are pleased that the friar is opposed to her attendance. Several of her clerical supporters attempt to change his mind, but to no avail. He will only permit her to join his sermons if she concedes that her behavior is the result of illness, which she refuses. Margery’s confessor orders her not to attend his sermons and instead visit other churches. This scenario goes on for years.

Many turn against Margery due to the friar’s sermons against her. Even the priestly scribe who records her book doubts her. However, after he reads about the life of Mary of Oignies, who experienced weeping episodes like Margery, he stops doubting. He likewise finds justification for such weeping in the writing of St. Bonaventure and experiences his own episode of uncontrolled sobbing during Mass. Other doubters also repent for having turned against Margery due to the friar’s sermons. Others maintain that she is possessed.