Content Warning: This summary section contains a depiction of sexual assault and an obscured quotation of an anti-gay slur.

Stewart is amused as he observes Ashley’s attempts to dislike Michael during Christmas dinner: “She so wanted to hate him, but everything he said to her was like another little ring of Pavlov’s bell. She couldn’t help but salivate” (187). Michael is a fashion sophisticate like Ashley. He works in advertising and offers Ashley a chance to attend a private sale of items that had been used in his film and commercial work. Although Ashley wants to disapprove of her father’s new boyfriend, she can’t help but be pleased to accept his offer.

After the fashion sale, Michael and Phil help Ashley home with her purchases. Just then, Jared arrives to make plans for New Year’s Eve. Ashley tries to cover up the relationship between Phil and Michael by introducing them to Jared as friends. She can tell that Michael is disappointed in her behavior.

When New Year’s Eve finally arrives, Stewart has made his own plans for a party. He’s invited Alistair, Phoebe, and Violet over for a Dr. Who marathon. Ashley announces that she has invited Jared, his friend Paolo, and her friend Lauren over as well and claims the family room for her group.